• 0 Posts
  • 18 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 13th, 2023

help-circle






  • Amju Wolf@pawb.socialtoLinux@lemmy.mlGNOME 47.beta Released
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 months ago

    I may understand “opinionated” differently from you, but the main issue is that when you do want to change something, you can’t. Or it’s some unsupported hack, or (best case) you flip some hidden configuration variable (that will probably break with the next release).

    KDE is well configured from the get go as well, you don’t have to change anything and it will work well. But if you do decide that you don’t like some of their defaults, you can tweak many aspects of it.


  • Amju Wolf@pawb.socialtoLinux@lemmy.mlGNOME 47.beta Released
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    arrow-down
    5
    ·
    3 months ago

    It wouldn’t really be an issue if you didn’t need an extension for every single basic functionality…

    Because of how stupidly opinionated Gnome is I switched to KDE a year or so ago and have been extremely happy with it. And what do you know I don’t even need any extensions, because sane stuff like tray icons are builtin.

    I do use an extension for distributing windows in custom areas though, and it didn’t even break throughout the (I believe) 2 large updates there were since I started using it.


  • That’s what PieFed changes though. You can still track how someone votes, but you can’t tie it to a specific profile (without doing some extra analysis and even then you can’t be completely sure).

    Or, with my suggestion, you could track how that specific account votes, but it would be easy to obfuscate who exactly it is and (hopefully) impossible to track to the user’s other identities.







  • When you comment you make a conscious decision to put your opinion out there and sign it with your “name” (or alternatively you switch to a “burner” account and do it pseudonymously).

    But when you vote for stuff it’s often without much thinking, and it’s private on pretty much every other platform. Where it isn’t it’s usually blatantly obvious that that is the case.

    What difference does it make that votes can be viewed, other than for transparency during discussion?

    There are many reasons that have been stated time and time again; one is simply that people may wish to stay anonymous when supporting certain opinions.

    To me it feels like comments are what you can actually stand behind publicly, while votes also show what you think privately. And not everyone is willing to stand behind all of their opinions publicly, often for fear of backlash or harassment.




  • Votes could be publicly federated but tied to some uuid instead of the username. That way you still have the same anti spam ability (can see that a user upvoted these things from this instance at this time) but can’t tie it directly to comments or actual user accounts without some extra osint.

    The issue with that is with malicious instances that could engage with vote manipulation by just generating new IDs and voting for whatever they want. If you can’t look back at the profile and determine whether it’s a real, non-spam account, it’s a pretty big issue unfortunately.

    You also have an issue where someone could potentially vote with “your” ID without any way to detect that it’s not actually “you” who sent the vote.