They’re both evil - evil people can do good things, but doing those good things doesn’t negate the evil things. Take the US: it’s done undeniably evil things, but at the same time it’s (by several measures) the #1 contributor of humanitarian aid to the world. So does this mean we be praising the US since by that metric it’s undeniably the global paragon of humanitarian charity? Or should we maybe be glad that the US is doing something not awful, while not accepting it as justification to dismiss the evil it also does?
The aid the US gives out is usually just given to compradors as bribes, it isn’t done with humanitarian intent but to keep the world under the thumb of imperialism.
Do you mean that if we added the values given for two distinct entities together, they would be larger than that of a single entity? That’s… sure, I’m not going to say that addition doesn’t exist. But if you used that when compiling the above statistics, you wouldn’t be comparing donations from distinct groups, and the meaning of the above statistic would be fundamentally changed.
It would be the contributions of all member states to the EC and then germany’s contributions added together, vs a single country (the US).
Which has nothing to do with Yemen’s human rights record, or the point I was making with that statistic, and is an intellectually valueless enterprise within that context.
The mass murder of gay people in Gaza by the West. Statistics estimate 5-10% of people are gay so that would be at least 3000-6000 gay people mass murdered by the West in Gaza. Assuming a low estimate of 3000:
Is 13 gay people killed is worse than 3000?
Of course not but you’re fine with the 3000, because the 3000 were gay people executed and blown up by the West, and not by brown people. And when white Ubermenschen with superior technological airplanes and snipers mass murder gay brown people it doesn’t count for you because they are brown Untermenschen and should know their place.
And not just gay people. Women, children, men, the West is just killing everyone. 60.000 at the very least already.
And who is defending those 3000 gay people killed by the West? That’s right, Yemen.
The existence of queer people in the general population isn’t in question, though. How that statistic is relevant to Yemen’s human right’s record is what we’re confused about.
Supporting and applauding Yemen’s blocade against Israel doesn’t mean one also supports every single one of their other actions, priorities need to be decided in times like these, same way it’s stupid to condemn Hamas when it’s literally resisting genocide.
Let me check my evil meter to find out if homophobia is worse than literal genocide against brown Untermenschen to create an ethnostate
They’re both evil - evil people can do good things, but doing those good things doesn’t negate the evil things. Take the US: it’s done undeniably evil things, but at the same time it’s (by several measures) the #1 contributor of humanitarian aid to the world. So does this mean we be praising the US since by that metric it’s undeniably the global paragon of humanitarian charity? Or should we maybe be glad that the US is doing something not awful, while not accepting it as justification to dismiss the evil it also does?
The aid the US gives out is usually just given to compradors as bribes, it isn’t done with humanitarian intent but to keep the world under the thumb of imperialism.
Okay. Do you have any evidence to support that claim?
Those people are suffering because of the US. If not for the US they wouldn’t even need aid.
This is soft power. The US demands things in return for that “aid”. It’s not aid whatsoever.
Germany lies within the EU so if you add 2 and 3 your argument falls apart.
I’m sorry, I’m really not sure what this means. What does germany have to do with this?
The top donor thing you talked about…
Do you mean that if we added the values given for two distinct entities together, they would be larger than that of a single entity? That’s… sure, I’m not going to say that addition doesn’t exist. But if you used that when compiling the above statistics, you wouldn’t be comparing donations from distinct groups, and the meaning of the above statistic would be fundamentally changed.
It would be the contributions of all member states to the EC and then germany’s contributions added together, vs a single country (the US).
Which has nothing to do with Yemen’s human rights record, or the point I was making with that statistic, and is an intellectually valueless enterprise within that context.
The US gives more than 3x as much money to bomb gay people in Gaza as the total they give to “aid”.
Which was a central concept of my point, yes exactly.
Nuance really is dead, huh?
You sure are nuancing away all the gay people in Gaza massacred by the West.
Literally what the fuck are you talking about? Jesus Christ way to prove the point.
The mass murder of gay people in Gaza by the West. Statistics estimate 5-10% of people are gay so that would be at least 3000-6000 gay people mass murdered by the West in Gaza. Assuming a low estimate of 3000:
Is 13 gay people killed is worse than 3000?
Of course not but you’re fine with the 3000, because the 3000 were gay people executed and blown up by the West, and not by brown people. And when white Ubermenschen with superior technological airplanes and snipers mass murder gay brown people it doesn’t count for you because they are brown Untermenschen and should know their place.
And not just gay people. Women, children, men, the West is just killing everyone. 60.000 at the very least already.
And who is defending those 3000 gay people killed by the West? That’s right, Yemen.
The existence of queer people in the general population isn’t in question, though. How that statistic is relevant to Yemen’s human right’s record is what we’re confused about.
They are fighting the worlds largest armies in order to stop genocide.
Sure, and that’s a good thing for them to be doing. What does that have to do with their human right’s record?
If you watch this video fully you’ll understand https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZc5Mbix3VE
Supporting and applauding Yemen’s blocade against Israel doesn’t mean one also supports every single one of their other actions, priorities need to be decided in times like these, same way it’s stupid to condemn Hamas when it’s literally resisting genocide.